In a television first, O.J. Simpson joins the cast of
HBOs 1st & Ten as a character much like himself who has sex with white
women as though his color was irrelevant. The audience is clearly not supposed to see
color. Fuhrman sees red. His obsession with O.J. begins.
He finds out all he can about the star, right down to the clothes he
wears and where he buys them. He spends extra time in airports. He learns that O.J.s
"child bride" (with brown hair like the little girl in Airplane! dyed
blond like the girl who played Goldie) was born in Germany. He learns that her mother was
a pure Aryan, born and raised in Germany. He learns all about Nicole's and O.J.'s friends
Al Cowlings, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Marcus Allen, who are as open about their relations
with white women as O.J. is. Cowlings is dating Nicoles sister, Denise.
Fuhrman's focus of action is narrowed by a movie called Guilty
Conscience, a meeting with a screenwriter named Laura Hart, and a test of power
between the LAPDs Lt. Peggy York and the Police Protective League. Through the
intervention of his union representative, he gets his way. By joining a gang/narcotics
unit, he had hoped to find O.J. mixed up in cocaine trafficking. He does not succeed with
that, but the job helps him to make some key contacts in the police serology lab and to
recruit covert operatives with no known links to him or the Police Protective
Leaguejunkies.
Evidence is stored at police headquarters in downtown LA where security
is a joke. This is why he can tell Laura Hart that he can create the evidence he needs
after his arrests. He cant do all of that right now, but hes working on it.
Soon, there wont be any locked doors he cant open.
He sees opportunity in striking up a friendship with a black cop called
Ron Shipp who has a background in psychology and is known as a buddy of Simpson. Shipp is
married, but tells his friends about the other women in his life. White women. Fuhrman
toys with the idea of murdering O.J. and setting up Shipp, Nicole, and Denise for the
fall. He, of course, would crack the case and become a media sensation. Hes open to
whatever he can use to make a name for himself and to destroy O.J. Simpson as a man and a
symbol. He doesnt want to make him a martyr. Thats the problem with killing
him outright. He has to find another way.
After arranging to meet O.J. and Nicole on a phantom domestic dispute
call, he gets Nicole to use 911 in the future without having to say a word about it. The
standard North American emergency number is written in bold letters on the rear quarter of
his police car. All he has to do is take a pointed look at the rear quarter of his police
squad car when O.J. isn't paying attention to him. Nicole is nobody's fool. She now has a
sure way to keep O.J. in line. For Fuhrman its a great way to establish a motive for
her and Shipp to kill O.J. The only question is, how many calls to 911 will it take to
establish a pattern of spouse abuse?
In 1986, he expresses his feelings about mixed couples to Kathleen Bell
in the most violent, racist terms when she casually mentions O.J.'s close friend, Marcus
Allen. Not only did she tell him that her white girlfriend, Andrea Terry, was attracted to
men like Allen, she thought that Fuhrman and Allen looked enough alike that Terry would
like Fuhrman, too. Thats what made him so angry, the thought that anyone, especially
a white woman, could think that he and a black man looked anything alike.
Still playing with ideas about O.J. and Nicole in 1987, he goes to
Robbery Detective School with Ron Phillips and learns how the pros open locked doors with
and without keys. Being a detective also gives him greater access to the evidence room and
contacts in the lab through which he can learn all he needs to know about the labs
personnel, its practices and its facilities. Now when he tells Laura Hart about the ease
with which he can make evidence say whatever he wants it to, the evidence that he can do
it is indisputable. The only safeguard against tampering by detectives is a key to a
locked door in the police station, which any robbery detective would have to know how to
circumvent.
His hopes of making it big in the movies through the producers Laura
Hart has introduced him to are dashed in 1988 when he sees a caricature of himself in The
Naked Gun paired with a nigger, Americas nigger, O.J. Simpson! He'd had every
reason to believe that Frank Drebin, who seemed to bear no resemblance to him when he was
created in 1982, had been permanently retired the same year. Now, after Laura Heart has
paraded him in front of all those Jew producers he sees something in the character he
hadn't seen before. He's sure that there's a connection. He feels humiliated and betrayed.
He is no longer just thinking about murder, hes thinking about Kathleen Bell and
Markus Allen. Hes thinking about body doubles, the niggers on death row and the Jews
who should be there. And hes making real plans to get even.
On the first day of 1989, Nicole gets drunk at a party. She
misinterprets a remark made by Marcus Allens wife to mean that O.J. bought an
expensive gift for another woman. She knows that he is cheating on her but she could never
prove it. Now that she thinks she has proof and O.J. is lying about it, she physically
attacks him in their bedroom and accuses him of having sex with Michelle, their maid.
During the scuffle, she bumps her head. O.J. grabs her in a headlock and forces her out of
the bedroom shouting and cursing at her as he always does when he is extremely angry. She
goes to the maids quarters from inside the house, cursing her and threatening her
with great bodily harm.
From this point on her hatred of O.J.'s housekeeper will be barely
restrained until she loses her temper again shortly before her death. It will begin with
an argument in the backyard. Michelle will leave. Nicole will follow. With no further
words between them, Nicole will punch her hard on the side of her face. That will be the
first time she physically assaults the tiny woman when she's not her usual pleasant self.
It will not be the first time she tried. The first time is now, on New Year's Day, 1989.
Michelle calls 911 while Nicole tries without success to enter her
room. The line stays open as Nicole disappears and Michelle waits, hoping that she
wont have to follow through on the call and no one will learn that she made it. But
Nicole has come out of the house and around to the side where she has used her master key
to get in. Michelle screams in surprise and fear as Nicole swings at her but misses.
She slaps Nicole as hard as she can. The blow lands on the side of Nicole's neck. Nicole
snatches the phone from Michelle's hand and hangs it up as Michelle grabs her by the hair
from behind. O.J. comes in, pushes Michelle aside and tussles with Nicole on Michelle's
bed, ranting all the while. He forces her outside, takes her master key to keep her from
getting back into Michelle's room and goes back to the main house. He locks her outside in
her bra and sweatpants and returns in a huff to his own room unaware that anyone has
called 911.
O.J. is as furious at Nicole's violent behavior as she is with his
philandering. She's wrong about the specifics but right about his cheating in general. And
now he won't let her in the house. And it's cold and damp. And she has already fallen down
in the mud behind the garage outside of Michelle's door. She is so angry and frustrated
she doesn't know which way to turn. What more can go wrong to start the new year?
Nicole sees a police car on Rockingham and hides in the bushes by the
Ashford gate, afraid that they have come to get her for assaulting her weaker,
smaller maid. To her horror, the police car turns the corner on Ashford and pulls up to
the intercom post on the driveway. From her concealed position, she can see two uniformed
officers. The male driver gets out of the car, rings the intercom and waits forever,
in Nicole's mind, for a reply. Will it be O.J. or Michelle? Will they team up against her
again? Did O.J. call some of his cop friends? Was there someone on the line when she got
to the phone? What did they hear?
Cold and frightened, Nicole stays out of sight until Michelle answers
the intercom. Officer Edwards identifies himself and asks what the problem is. This is the
moment she's been dreading. Where can she go half-clothed if Michelle buzzes him in?
Nowhere.
Michelle tells Edwards that there are no problems. He answers by
telling her that a woman called 911 and said that she was being beaten. He says that he
isn't going to leave until he speeks to her.
That's it! Nicole's way out, and her chance to hit back the way she'd
tried to do with the calls she had actually made to 911. She realizes that she must have
some marks on her body that match the officer's idea of what had happened and Michelle
didn't. Only then does she come out of hiding, open the gate and fall into the officer's
arms. No one ever asks her why she remained hidden and silent for so long with the police
only a few feet away. No one asks why she didnt open the gate and seek their
protection immediately if she was in imminent fear of being killed by her husband.
No one wants to hear O.J.s or the maids version of what
happened, or why Michelle came outside, pleaded with Nicole to stop what she was doing and
tried to pull her out of the police car by her arm. Nicoles physical appearance and
her cries of, "Hes going to kill me!" are as far as anyone can see or hear
or think.
Fuhrman studies the case and figures out the real story with
Nicoles confidential confession to Ron Shipp to confirm it. The confession is only
frosting on the cake. Time talks. Space talks. O.J. always talked loudly and continuously
when he was extremely angry with Nicole the way he was doing when he came out of the house
and saw Nicole with the police.
The time between the squad car's arrival and Nicole's emergence from
hiding tells Fuhrman that she wasn't waiting there for the police. With O.J. nowhere in
sight and a closed door between him and Nicole, she would have dashed for the gate
immediately if O.J. had just thrown her out. But if he had beaten her, thrown her out and
closed himself in behind the door she couldn't have seen him as a threat to her life when
the police arrived. And if O.J. had been the one who slapped her when the emergency line
was open, where was all of his shouting and cursing during the slapping and the three
minutes of silence that preceded it?
Nicole's story is a poor match for the evidence, and Edwards'
assumptions about the 911 call are demonstrably false. Yet, the department is following
through on the complaint as though there was no rational question of O.J.'s guilt. The
only thing anyone wants to know is whether the wife-beating incident is isolated to that
one time or part of a pattern. Fuhrman has thus seen what will happen if Nicole's
words and the condition of her body say the perpetrator was O.J. no matter what anyone or
anything else might have to say. He knows that photos of her with mud on her pants and a
bruise on her head will be interpreted according to the officers verbal description
of a cut lip, a black eye and swollen face.
By paying attention to details that everyone else dismissed and
reserving judgment until he was sure he had all the facts, Fuhrman knows more about what
really happened than anyone, including O.J. or Nicole. He knows that Michelles
handprint was on Nicoles neck, Michelle pulled her hair and Michelle left the bruise
on her right arm when she was trying to pull her from the police car. No one has bothered
to add up all of the facts, just the obvious ones. He knows that nothing was as it
appeared because of a compounding of assumptions beginning with the 911 call that made
Nicole look like the victim of a violent crime perpetrated by O.J. Simpson. Even his best
friend believes from the evidence he's seen that O.J. must have hit her. Plus, she did say
that O.J. was going to kill her.
Change of plans. Nicole is going to die violently. The obvious killer
is going to be O.J. Simpson, the wife beater.
Nobody is going to take the word of a rich black man and a lowly
Filipino maid in Brentwood over the word of a white police officer and a white, female
victimespecially a dead one. Everyone is going to "see" what he tells them
is there whether the photographs confirm it or not. That pattern has been set. He knows
what to expect. Everybody is going to see "Nordberg" as the killer, which will
also kill The Naked Gun. And everyone is going to think, Othello in a
blue knit cap.
Visions of Laurence Olivier and Ronald Coleman in blackface race across
Fuhrmans mind. He sees Shelly Winters in Night of the Hunter and the
cake-cutting scene in The Naked Gun. Each vision pulls another behind it in
tandem, like convicts linked by a single chain. He sees the long-bladed knife and the
glove holding it. He sees the Swiss Army knife connection to a very unusual shoe. He sees
Anthony Hopkins from Guilty Conscience on an airplane falsely accused of murder,
Swoosie Kurtz following Blythe Danner into a shoe store, and "Nordbergs"
shoes on "Drebins" feet. He sees a letter addressed to the district
attorney telling him to assume the husband's guilt in case the wife is murdered. Its
all there. Now all he has to do is put it together with only the tiniest bit of editing to
fit the existing facts and circumstances.
Fuhrman writes a letter to the Brentwood city attorney that results in
Simpsons arrest and public branding as a batterer. That letter gives every 911 call
attributed to Nicole, without testimony or evidence that O.J. touched her, the same weight
as the call she was assumed to have made in 89. He knows that she didnt make
that call. Hes the only one who bothered to look at all of the evidence before
deciding how it had to fit together. He now knows how little it will take for the
appearance of truth to overwhelm the real thing. The 85 incident he writes about in
his letter to the city attorney can be seen as an example of spouse abuse only through the
prism of what everyone thinks O.J. did to Nicole on New Years Day. By that standard,
a loud shouting match with the right spin on it would have sufficed.
Fuhrmans account of the 85 incident will stand unchallenged
for years. His portrait of O.J., the pimp-like controller wielding a deadly weapon will
appear in a diary allegedly written by Nicole, in a phone call allegedly made by her, and
in the testimony of Denise Brown, Faye Resnick and Ron Shipp. It will be lifted whole
cloth by Marcia Clark and Chris Darden, who will never trace it back to its origin.
Aaronson,
EllenWalked past 875 South Bundy with Danny Mandel between 10:28-10:30
on the evening or June 12, without seeing the open gate, Nicoles body, her blood or
the bloody paw prints of her dog. They never heard the dog bark. That narrowed the window
of opportunity too much for O.J. to have gotten rid of some evidence and done everything
consistent with all of the other evidence found at Rockingham by Detective Mark Fuhrman
and his partner Brad Roberts. In the civil case, the plaintiffs had to accept the timing
of the murders bracketed by the testimony of Aaronson, Mandel and others because there was
no credible way around it.
Abrams, DanReporter/commentator
for Court TV. During the criminal trial against O.J. Simpson, Abrams established himself
as a national, five-star expert on the case. In the civil trial, Abrams reported that
photos of O.J. wearing Bruno Magli shoes supposedly taken by a young photographer named E.
J. Flammer, were "proof that O.J. Simpson is a killer." The admission of the
plaintiffs former FBI experts under cross-examination that the photos could have
been faked, did not prompt Abrams to retract his earlier statement. He had spoken the
minds of the vast majority of his colleagues who have since referred to the Flammer photos
as proof of O.J.s guilt, and used them to ridicule anyone who disagrees.
Abudrahn, MichelleO.J.
Simpsons Filipino housekeeper. She left O.J.s employ in April, 1994 when
Nicole struck her hard enough to knock her down and leave her face red and swollen. The
genesis of the assault may have gone back to 1989 when Nicole told police, responding to
an anonymous 911 call, that O.J. beat her with his fists, kicked her and pulled her hair.
Michelle Abudrahn sided with O.J. in saying that nothing like that happened. Nicole
allowed others to assume that she called 911 (see Edwards, John) but never said so
herself. In O.J.s first public comment about the episode shortly after it happened,
he told an interviewer that the maid called 911 as an "overreaction" to
something she heard. Evidence suggests that she did make the call, that she left the line
open rather than report a problem because she was afraid that she might have been
overreacting. Evidence suggests that she was the one who was heard screaming on the 911
tape, and that she was the one who slapped Nicole firstin 1989.
Adlen, AndrewBuyer of
cars auctioned and impounded by police. A business competitor (see Balasini, William)
identified him as a fellow witness to the accessibility of O.J.s Bronco in a
"restricted" area of Viertels garage on June 21, and the lack of blood
inside. Mr. Adlen was not called to testify by either side.
AkitaA breed of dog. An Akitas,
Kato, and a Chow, Chachi, were owned jointly by Nicole and O.J. When the Simpsons
separated, Kato went with Nicole; Chachi went with O.J. Both Nicole and O.J. frequently
picked up the dog in the others care, O.J. transporting them mostly in his Bronco
(probable source of Bronco fibers on Bundy)Kato had a habit of running off whenever the
gate was opened. He was outside of the gate when the killing started. O.J. said that he
took Chachi out for a walk around 10:00. The blood drop pattern at the Rockingham gate
matches his account. He didnt know when or how he was cut.
While pointing out the relationship of the blood drop on Bundy to the
left of the left shoeprint, Fuhrman theorized it was the killers blood, and that the
Akita had bitten the killer.
AlibiA conflict in time,
place or circumstance that makes it impossible for someone to have committed a crime.
O.J. could not have committed the murders he was charged with. Mark Fuhrman could have. An
innocent person need not have a perfect alibi. But to frame him, the people doing the
framing have to know that he does not have one.
The defense teams failure to consider the possibility that O.J.
was set up by a small group of conspirators well in advance of the murders left them
vulnerable to the prosecutions argument that a police conspiracy was impossible. The
sheer size of such a conspiracy, after the fact, along with the belief that none of the
officers involved could have known whether or not O.J. had an alibi, gave the police an
alibi.
Attorneys for the defense and prosecution argued that O.J.s
Bronco was crucial to the question of whether or not he could have committed the murders.
If the defense could show that it was in the same place before during and after the murder
O.J. would have an alibi; if the prosecution could show that it wasnt, he
wouldnt.
Neither side was able to prove its contention. However, the slight
angle to the curb at which the Bronco was parked gave rise to Det. Mark Fuhrmans
theory that the driver parked it in great haste after returning from Bundy. He testified
during the preliminary hearing that the back stuck out as much as "a foot"
farther than the front, an angle of 10 degrees or more. The actual angle was 2 degrees,
which amounts to an error too great to have been arrived at accidentally by a trained
observer. Though O.J. pointed out the sharp turn he had to make to go from his drive to
the street, his defense team did not match the angle that would have resulted from that
turn to the angel found by police. That angle, together with the pattern of blood drops on
his driveway gave him an airtight alibi.
Mark Fuhrmans partner, Brad Roberts, characterized the droplets
of blood on O.J.s driveway as going into the compound. They couldnt have been.
The width of the gate, where it was hinged, and the width of O.J.s body could only
have meant that he left his blood on the driveway on his way out. Roberts was the only
detective to get close enough to them to see whether they showed a tell-tale spread of
finger-like projections from the droplets in the direction of travel. The photos
didnt show it, and the criminalists didnt say it. The pattern itself, however,
could not have been made by a man with a cut on the left side of his body as large as O.J.
had when he returned from Chicago. The size of the droplets could have been made only by
someone with a superficial cut, which O.J. said he had before he left for Chicago.
Allport, Dr. Gordon W.Author
of The Nature of Prejudice. Allport literally wrote the book on prejudice, from its
biological, historical and cultural origins to its various manifestations and implications
in predicting human behavior. Many people unfamiliar with Allports work believe that
a white racist like Mark Fuhrman is incapable of having a black friend like Ron Shipp.
Those who are familiar with Allports work know that allowing for exceptions to the
rule is an essential component of prejudice. It is the only way to maintain the illusion
of rational judgment about stereotypes or to see oneself as fair-minded in the face of
obvious cases in which the rule does not apply. Allport showed how stubborn stereotypes
were, partly because of how natural it is for human beings to see complete and inaccurate
images when presented with partial or contradictory facts. Such facts are replete in the
O.J. Simpson murder case. Only someone familiar with Allports work could have gotten
others to "see" O.J. as a spouse-abuser and a murderer if the available evidence
did not support those assertions. Without the involvement of Mark Fuhrman and Ron Shipp,
the available evidence would not support that assertion. One of the difficulties in
pinning Fuhrman down as the killer was in showing that he knew enough about Allport to
make practical use of his discoveries. He studied enough psychology to think that he could
fool the experts on the police force in 1982 and 83. Its difficult to see how
he could have done that without knowing about Allport. The fact that he chose to put a
picture in his first book that showed Marcia Clark holding a copy of The Nature of
Prejudice speaks for itself.
Alonzo, Rosa ElviaNicoles
housekeeper. Ms. Alonzo told police that a key ring with many keys that Nicole kept on
a hook in her kitchen disappeared between June 5 and June 6, 1994 (see Keys).
Allen, MarcusFriend
of O.J. Simpson and Al Cowlings. The three black men were known to socialized together
in the company of white women throughout the 80s. Allen eventually married his blond
girlfriend at O.J.s house. Before they met in 1988, Allen would often go out with
O.J. and Nicole. Kathleen Bells casual mention of Allen to Mark Fuhrman in 1986 is
what triggered his enraged diatribe about his practice of harassing mixed couples and his
fantasies of committing genocide.
Ameli, Dr. JenniferClinical
psychologist specializing in intimate relationships and drug abuse. Both Nicole and
Ron Goldman were under her care at the time of their deaths. Amelis office was
broken into and bugged, files were stolen and she was subjected to anonymous threats to
keep her mouth shut about her knowledge of the murder victims. All she could say about one
man who approached her from behind and threatened her was that he was tall.
Baden, Dr. MichaelOne
of the worlds leading forensic pathologists. He offered his services to the
prosecution as well as the defense. The prosecution turned him down. Hired by the defense
for his technical ability as well as his pristine reputation for integrity, he was
ridiculed by the vast majority of media commentators for saying that Goldman could have
stayed on his feet for as long as five or ten minutes after his throat was slit. Either
estimate makes it impossible for O.J. to have committed the crime.
Bailey, F. LeeFamous
defense attorney and polygraph expert. Two days after the murders, he stopped O.J.
from completing a polygraph test as soon as he discovered he was taking one. The reason he
gave was the same one Mark Fuhrman used for waiting over a year to take his: To get a
reliable reading the person being tested has to be as stress-free as possible. During
Simpsons criminal trial, Bailey maneuvered Fuhrman into committing perjury under
cross-examination by asking him if hed used the n-word or referred to any black
person by that name in the past ten years. But he ruled out Fuhrman as a murder suspect
because he was convinced that Fuhrman found the bloody right-hand glove at Bundy after he
was called in on the case, and planted it at Rockingham to stay involved in the case.
Baker, PhillipAttorney
for O.J. Simpson. His questioning of Denise Brown uncovered a vital link between her,
Ron Shipp and Faye Resnick, whom she said she didnt know. He asked her if Shipp and
Resnick were passengers in her car when she was stopped in LA for drunk driving. Her
Attorney, John Kelley, told her not to answer; leaving a strong impression that any answer
she gave would be incriminating. The only incriminating truthful answer she could have
given would have been, yes; her only incriminating false answer would have been, no. The
only logical conclusion being, she lied about her relationship with Faye Resnick and Ron
Shipp, the most damaging witness against Simpson other than Mark Fuhrman and herself.
Baker, RobertO.J.s
lead attorney in the civil trial, father of Phillip Baker. Under state legislation
fashioned specifically for the Simpson case, Baker was forced to contend with devastating
hearsay evidence purported to have been said or written by Nicole. Under the rulings of
the presiding judge, he was not allowed to call Mark Fuhrman or to suggest that Fuhrman
had anything to do with planting evidence. He was able to show how and why photos of O.J.
Simpson wearing shoes identified as the killers could have been faked. But, by all
published accounts, he showed no enthusiasm for his own argument and some writers claimed
he was angry with O.J. for lying to him. Transcripts do show tension between Baker and
O.J. when O.J. insisted on answering questions against his attorneys advice.
However, that advice made sense only if one assumed that he would hurt himself by
answering them. He didnt.
Barbiari, PaulaO.J.
Simpsons former girlfriend. On the morning of June 12, 1994, Barbiari left a
message on Simpsons answering machine telling him that their relationship was over.
The prosecution argued that her message set off a slow-burning fuse in Simpson, which
exploded that night in the rage killing of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman. They
offered no proof of that scenario, their only evidence being the mood some witnesses said
he was in at his daughters dance recital before the killing. However, a video taken
without the knowledge of O.J. or any of those witnesses, showed the opposite of what they
said.
Baur, MariaFormer
housekeeper for O.J. and Nicole. Her husband Rolf was Nicoles cousin, brought
over from Germany by O.J. and Nicole. During her four years with Nicole and O.J. at
Rockingham from 1980 to 1984, she witnessed no displays of temper by O.J., saw no bruises
on Nicole and testified that her family didnt believe her stories of O.J.s
physical abuse. She saw no evidence of it.
Baur, RolfFormer
groundskeeper for O.J. and Nicole. He lived with the Browns from the time he was
9-years-old. He worked with his wife at Rockingham for 3 years without seeing evidence
that O.J. abused Nicole. He did tell investigators of seeing a picture "long
before" that showed her "beaten up." He said that it was taken by her
father. He didnt say who beat her up, if anyone (see Brown, Denise) and Nicole never
mentioned it to him, his wife, the police or her divorce lawyer.
Bell, KathleenWitness
for the defense. She met Fuhrman at a Marine recruiting station in Redondo Beach in
the summer of 86. He was wearing a sweatsuit. Noting how tall he was, she wanted to
fix him up with her girlfriend, Andrea Terry, who was 6 tall. She told Fuhrman that
her friend liked men who fit his general description. Terry was white, but color was not
important to Bell, who gave Marcus Allen as an example (could be where he got the idea
that he might be able to impersonate O.J.) of the kind of man she was talking about.
Horrified at his violent, racist reaction, she avoided him and the
places she saw his pea-green and white International Harvester Scout. When she was
visiting Hennesseys Tavern in Redondo Beach with Andrea Terry, she saw Fuhrman at a
table with another woman. Bell pointed him out to Terry as the reason she wanted to leave.
After saying that he did not recall meeting Bell, Fuhrman claimed that
she sought him out at Hennesseys after the alleged incident at the recruiting
station, to introduce Terry to him. He then pointed out the logical inconsistency in his
version of events between the two stories. Marcia Clark used that argument as the basis
for calling Bell a liar, until the language and content of the McKinny tapes lent
credibility to Bells version of what happened. Clark never apologized to Bell.
Berris, KennethChicago
Policeman. He searched the room where O.J. was staying when he got the call from
Detective Ron Phillips that his ex-wife had been murdered. O.J. almost certainly cut
himself on purpose in that room to make it appear that he could not have left his blood at
his home. Whether he actually did it by accident, as he claimed, as a panic reaction to
details of the murder he wasnt supposed to be told, or as a calculated attempt to
hide evidence of his guilt, there is no doubt that he cut himself in Chicago. But when
prosecutors learned that the blood drops on O.J.s driveway came from a superficial
cut (see Chapter 30: Blood Trails), and no one could testify to seeing a cut of any kind
on his hand before he left, they had a problem. They were forced to argue that O.J. did
not cut himself in Chicago at all. Though the bedding where the blood appeared in photos
was shipped back to LA, the prosecution still used Berris testimony that he saw a
ballpoint pen on the bed, to suggest that the red stain was red ink.
Blasier, RobertDNA
expert, defense attorney for O.J. Simpson in his criminal and civil trial. Coached
Johnnie Cochran and Bob Shapiro on questions related to blood and fiber evidence. He was
first to propose the theory that Mark Fuhrman found the bloody glove on Bundy and planted
it on Rockingham.
Blasini, WilliamGeneral
manager of vehicle purchasing for a large, self-service automobile recycling center.
On Tuesday, June 21, he visited Virtels garage where O.J.s Bronco was taken on June
13. He went there as part of his routine practice of buying cars from police auctions and
impounds. Hed been involved in the business for 15 years and had seen hundreds of
vehicles with bloodstains inside of them. He had heard about the killings and expected to
see a great deal of blood on the seats, doors, instrument panel, console and carpet. He
looked for blood. Andrew Adlen, the competing buyer who was with him, also looked for
blood. They discussed the absence of blood. They noticed that a section of the carpet had
been cut out, but they saw no blood anywhere.
Two other people, a man who stole some receipts and a police officer
who investigated the theft, also reported that they saw no blood when they were inside of
the vehicle. When Marcia Clark confronted them with photos supposedly taken on the 14th of
June and the 1st of August with clear indications of blood on the door, the instrument
panel and the console, they conceded that they might not have noticed it. The photos did
not change Blasinis mind.
Bodziak, WilliamFBI
footwear expert. Of all the shoes in the FBIs extensive library, the ones that
left their clear, size-12 imprint on the murder scene at Bundy were not among them. Agent
Bodziak took weeks to track down the imprint and identify it as a Silga sole pattern used
on rare and expensive Italian dressy/casual shoes (or boots) called Bruno Magli Lorenzos.
They had soft-leather, high-quarter tops and distinctive rubber treads. Bodziak discovered
that they were sold in the United States exclusively though Bloomingdales in 1991
and 92.
Bodziak was one of two FBI experts called by the prosecution to rebut
the testimony of defense expert Henry Lee that a less distinct set of imprints with
simple, parallel lines might also be shoeprintsthe shoeprints of a smaller man with
a smaller foot. When you hear that only one set of bloody shoeprints was discovered at the
crime scene, you are listing to the opinions of William Bodziak (shoe expert) and Douglas
Deedrick (fiber expert). Bodziak consulted his library on the second set of possible
shoeprints. When he found no match, he did no further research before concluding that
there were no shoes in the world that matched. He went so far as to say that Lee had
misidentified a concrete impression as a surface imprint.
Bowers, JarvisAn
African-American choke hold victim of Mark Fuhrman. In 1984, when Fuhrmans
medical retirement claim was denied, his superiors assigned him to a predominately white
area. There, he stopped Bowers for jaywalking, put him in a coke hold and threatened to
kill him. This story was not uncovered by any of the official investigators who were
supposed to be looking for evidence of Fuhrmans abuse of power even though Bowers
made an official complaint. Jeffrey Toobin reported it in his best-selling anti-O.J. book,
The Run of His Life. His wife, who knew Bowers personally and professionally, told
the story to him.
Brockbank, SusanLAPD
criminalist. She testified that a patch of carpet the criminalist cut from the Bronco
to test for blood, was stored inside of the same battered, cardboard box as all the
evidence its fibers was found on. That includes the carpet fibers found on the gloves, the
knit cap and Ron Goldmans shirt.
Brown, DeniseOlder
sister of Nicole Brown Simpson. She was with Nicoles party at the Mezzaluna
restaurant where her mothers glasses disappeared shortly before the murders. Of the
four adults living in her parents home when police called there at 6:20 a.m. to
inform the family that Nicole was dead, Denise was the one who reacted first when her
father answered the phone and got the horrible new. For some unexplained reason, she was
up and listening in on another extension. She was the one who screamed, "O.J. did
it!" the instant her father got the news. No one thought to ask her why she behaved
as though she were expecting an important call before she learned of her sisters
death.
According to Joe Bosco, she was the only person who reported seeing
O.J. wearing Bruno Magli Lorenzos.
She cashed in big on her sisters murder by accusing O.J. of a
pattern of abuse against Nicole typical of men who have gone on to kill their wives or
ex-wives. The textbook case of spouse-abuse she presented to authorities was the one Ron
Shipp taught in the police academy, the one he taught Nicole and the one Faye Resnick
wrote about in her best-selling books. The similarities in the tone and language of their
reports are striking. They are supported mostly by Nicoles initial statement to
police about the 89 incident, when she was drunk, angry, and under the false
impression that O.J. had given an expensive set of earrings to another woman. They
contrast strikingly with reports of others who knew them well and had nothing to gain by
what they said. Those people said that Nicole was the one who did the hitting.
The only photos purporting to show Nicole
battered by O.J., other than the ones taken by Officer Edwards on the 1st of January,
1989, is the one Denise said she took and her cousin Rolph Baur said that her father took.
The prosecution tried to imply that it was what Nicole really looked like as a result of
being beaten by O.J. in 1989, but the photographic paper showed that it couldnt have
been taken later than 1979. In this one, Nicole appeared to have been battered badly
enough to require hospitalization and reconstructive surgery. O.J. said that she was
wearing makeup for a part in a movie. The date on the photographic paper corresponded to
the date of the movie. Still, no one questioned how it ended up with
"Nicoles" month-old will in a safe deposit box supposedly secured by
Nicole shortly before her death
Brown, DominiqueDenises
younger sister. She lived with Denise in New York before O.J. married Nicole and put
her through college. Dominique had no stories to tell of Nicole being threatened or abused
by O.J. However, before 1996, she was the only person other than Denise who reported
having seen O.J. in Bruno Magli shoes. According to Tom Lange and Phil Vannatters
book, Evidence Dismissed, she "made the right choice" by picking a pair
of low-quarter Bruno Maglis that she said she saw him wear the Easter before the murders.
Though it was reported in the book that she made the right choice (see Bruno Magli
Lorenzos), that report was in error. She did not point to Bruno Magli Lorenzos. She did,
however, recognize the Bruno Magli logo and took off one of her shoes to show Det. Lange
that she was wearing a pair of Bruno Maglis that Nicole had purchased for herself in New
York.
Brown, JudithaNicoles
mother, a German national who became an American citizen when she married Louis Brown.
Her stories of Nicole living in fear of O.J. first surfaced after the murdersand
after the family was advised that they had one year from the date of Nicoles death
to sue O.J. Simpson for wrongful death. She forgot exculpatory information about
O.J.s relationship with Nicole, and remembered incriminating facts incompletely or
out of context. Her stories changed to conform to those told by her oldest daughter, the
police, the prosecutors and the media. By the time the civil case came around, she had
changed completely from a mother who doubted that her former son-in-law was guilty,
despite the evidence against him, to one who had been certain of his guilt from the start.
In regard to Nicoles credibility, she once said, "Nicole
could convince anyone of anything." Her own credibility was damaged beyond hope of
repair when Robert Baker caught her gently in a significant contradiction. She told the
jury that O.J. did not deny, being involved in Nicoles death when she asked him if
he had anything to do with it. She quoted him as saying, "I loved your
daughter," and nothing more. But in a taped statement she made in her first
television interview she quoted him as saying, "No, I loved your daughter."
Brown, LouisNicoles
Father. He accepted everything O.J. gave him, which included his successful business
and wealthy life-style, without complaint about the older mans treatment of his
daughter. He accepted money from the public, complaining about the extra cost of taking
care of Nicoles children without acknowledging the fact that O.J., while he was in
jail, was sending him $10,000 a month. He tried to sell pictures of Nicole in the nude and
rights to her alleged diary. He referred to her children, in their presence, as
"niggers." He answered the phone when police called to inform the family of
Nicoles violent death.
The will that Nicole supposedly left in a safe deposit box (no one at
the bank ever testified to seeing and talking to her in person about the box) left nearly
three-quarters of a million dollars to her father. Louis Brown also authenticated the diary Nicole supposedly wrote that paints a picture of O.J. as
the Devil himself and helped win the plaintiffs a multi-million dollar wrongful death
settlement.
Brown, TanyaNicoles
youngest sister. Although convinced of O.J.s guilt, Tanya did not describe O.J.
in the menacing way her mother or her older sister did. She called him, "A wonderful
guy."
Buffalo Bills ReportThe
newsletter for the Buffalo Bills football team fan club. E. J. Flammer was working for
the Buffalo Bills Report when he took the 30 photos showing O.J. in the
murderers shoes. One reason Dan Abrams was so impressed with Flammers photos,
was the assertion of Bills PR director Denny Lynch that one was printed in the Report
ten months before the murders. No subscriber to the newsletter ever came forward with his
or her own copy of it. That never became an issue for the media, whose purchase of them
for an undisclosed, amount of money, gave them a proprietary interest in promoting their
authenticity.
The photos were admitted into evidence only after the photo expert for
the defense made fundamental errors in fraud-detection that could easily be rebutted.
That, in turn, caused the photos to come in so late that it was impossible for the defense
to mount a counter-attack as dramatic as the introduction of the photos. Still, Bob and
Phillip Baker managed to show that all of the requirements for fake photos were met in the
professional qualifications and motivations of the people involved. The plaintiffs did not
produce a single witness other than Flammer and Scull to testify to having seen any of
them before the murders.
Cale, CharlesThe
spokesman for a group of O.J.s Rockingham neighbors who wanted him out of the
neighborhood. He testified in the criminal trial that he was walking his dog past the
Rockingham estate during the time Marcia Clark said it was missing. He said under direct
that he had a clear view of Rockingham and did not see the Bronco. He said under cross
that he also had a clear view of Ashford where Katos Nissan was parked. He said that
he didnt see the Nissan, either. He was not prosecuted for perjury or called as a
witness in the civil trial.
California State
Court of AppealsWhen Laura Hart McKinnys tapes of Mark Fuhrman
proved that he lied under oath, O.J.s defense asked Judge Ito to instruct the jury
as to why the detective was not called back to testify. Ito agreed with the defense and
the prosecution appealed his decision. The Appeals Court agreed with the prosecution and
issued the judge a public rebuke. The higher court was so concerned about Fuhrmans
rights in this regard that it issued a special order for Ito not to tell the jury why he
was dismissed prematurely. By affirming Mark Fuhrmans right against
self-incrimination for perjury, the Court of Appeals allowed to stand, his incriminating
testimony against Simpson. Most of that testimony and the fruit of his efforts regarding
that testimony still stands in the popular culture as "proof of O.J.s
guilt."
Cantor, BrettNightclub
owner, promoter, West LA murder victim. Nicole and Faye Resnick were frequent visitors
to his Dragonfly club. Ron Goldman worked for him briefly and also partied at the
Dragonfly with Nicole and Faye. Someone killed him at home in a manner similar to Ron,
with multiple stabbing and slashing wounds. Like Nicole, he was nearly decapitated.
These similarities could be written off as meaningless coincidence
except for the fact that they fit a requirement for a military-style assassination.
Its not likely that anyone trained in military operations would carry out a life or
death mission without detailed planning that included extensive intelligence gathering,
dry runs, and a "dress rehearsal."
The bloody assault on Cantor occurred five months before a man who was
following Nicole and keeping a detailed log of her daily activities got arrested for
steeling Paula Barbiaris white sports utility vehicle (see Wasz, William). Because
of his fathers standing as a well-known agent in the entertainment business, the
Robbery/Homicide Division was called in to investigate. His murder was never solved. It
also provided a preview of the legal apparatus that would be called into action in any
high-profile murder in Brentwood.
CasioA character in
Shakespeares Othello. Iago, who was jealous of Casio for passing him over as
General Othellos second in command, set him up to make Othello believe that he was
having an affair with Othellos wife, Desdemona. Iago contrived to have him and
Desdemona murdered. The attack on Casio was botched and he survived (see Rodrigo).
Chain of custodyA
procedure for safeguarding the integrity of evidence from collection to testing. American
military servicemen in Vietnam were given urine tests to determine if they were using
illegal drugs. The troops who were taking those drugs regularly beat the test by
substituting drug-free samples from other servicemen for their own. By 1975 when Mark
Fuhrman served aboard ship in Vietnam as a military policeman, this simple substitution
trick was well known to military police in all branches of the service. Blood evidence in
the O.J. Simpson case was subject to the same false identification for the same reason:
there was no procedure in place to insure that the samples being tested had an unbroken
connection to the source.
Clark, MarciaDeputy
DA for Los Angeles County. The week before the murders, she headed a department of her
own, but took a substantial cut in pay and power to work for Bill Hodgman of the Major
Crimes Unit of the LA County DAs Office. Like its elite Robbery/Homicide counterpart
in the LAPD, the Major Crimes Unit of the LADA Office was where all high-profile cases in
Los Angeles ended up. Clark had a reputation for bending over backwards to help police and
to prosecute men accused of spouse-abuse. She was particularly well known for helping
police clean up illegal searches, taking calls at any time or any place to assist a
detective in need of remedial action.
The DAs office had many deputy DAs who would not have
approached the case against O.J. with her single-minded interest in equating a
"search for truth" with her search for evidence of his guilt. None of them
belonged to the Major Crimes Unit. It would have been easy for a detective to insure that
Marcia Clark would be called in on the case at the very beginning, and that a like-minded
team would be assembled around her. He needed only to understand the system and to bend a
few rules on search and seizure.
CocaineThe illegal drug
thought by many to be the cause of the South Bundy murders. At one time or another,
O.J., Nicole, Denise, Faye Resnick, Ron Goldman, Ron Shipp and Keith Zlomawitz were all
subjects of police investigations involving cocaine. William Wasz, the man who stole Paula
Barbiaris car and made a detailed log of Nicoles daily activities, was a crack
addict. Mark Fuhrman worked in a gang/narcotics unit from 1885-87 where he made
numerous arrests for crimes involving cocaine, and may have had O.J. under surveillance
for drug trafficking in 85. Michelle Kestler, head of the LAPDs Scientific
Investigation Division (SID) had a background in illegal drugs, including cocaine. She set
up the lab security procedures primarily to guard against the theft of narcotics. Her only
safeguard against evidence tampering by police was a standard lock on an ordinary door and
a limited number of authorized keys.
Aspects of the murders consistent with a drug hit were seized upon by
the defense as evidence that drug lords committed the murders. Their investigation of Faye
Resnick focused on her possible connection to vicious drug dealers. No attempts were made
to link her to Mark Fuhrman or Brad Roberts. No attempt was made to determine if there was
a direct link between Kestler and Fuhrman or Fuhrman and Yamauchi (see Yamauchi), the lab
technician who prepared the blood samples for analysis by outside laboratories.
Cochran, Johnnie L. Jr.O.J.s
lead defense attorney, Court TV talk show host, and first cousin of Ron Shipp. The
record is clear that he acted not only brilliantly but also honorably in defense of O.J.
Simpson. The idea that he performed cynically, rests on the belief that he knew O.J. was
guilty, and used the charge of racism as an emotional smokescreen to hide the truth (see
Race Card).
Cochran was excoriated by some Jewish commentators and organizations
for his equation of Mark Fuhrman to the ambitious Adolph Hitler before the Jewish
Holocaust. He was further criticized for asking the "black jury" to "send a
message" that "genocidal racists" like Fuhrman would not be tolerated in
positions of power in America. There is, however, evidence that Fuhrman did pattern
himself after Hitler, and did identify with the notion of Aryan superiority and racial
purity. There is evidence that Nicoles "German blood" had much to do with
his obsession with the father of her children. There is evidence that Fuhrman did study
Hitlers principles of mass mind control, and did aspire to a position of political
influence in America.
In his book, Journey to Justice, Cochran apologized for his
remarks.
Colby, CarlNeighbor of
Nicole when she lived on Gretna Green in 1993. Called as a stalking witness against
O.J., Colby revealed under cross-examination that he didnt recognize O.J. Simpson
when he saw him around Nicoles house. He called 911 because the man he saw was
black. Colby didnt think a black man belonged in the neighborhood. He found out that
the man was O.J. when Nicole told him that he was there because she was worried about
someone following her (see Wasz, William), and asked O.J., among others, to look out for
her and the kids.
Coleman, LucienneDeputy
DA, former friend of Marcia Clark. She believed that O.J.s defense team was
making false charges of racism and evidence planting against Mark Fuhrman until she
checked it out. She, and two other deputy DAs, found that he openly admired the
ideas and symbols of Nazi Germany. Coleman and the other deputy DAs investigating
Fuhrman learned from several officers that his statements to them a few years before the
murders suggested that hed had an intimate relationship with Nicole. At the very
least, his knowledge of her breast implant surgery showed a special interest in her that
predated her death, and, by implication, a special interest in O.J. Simpson. When she
reported her findings to Marcia Clark and her boss Bill Hodgman, Clark screamed at her and
kicked her out of the office. Hodgman "did not recall" the incident.
Cowlings, Allen C.O.J.
Simpsons best friend and a trusted friend of Nicole. He drove O.J. in the
so-called "low-speed chase," pleading with him not to take his own life. His
candid answers to police, prosecutors, judges and juries, which didnt always help
O.J., made him a credible witness.
He took Nicole to St. Johns Hospital in Santa Monica on the
evening of the 89 incident when she complained of a headache. Seeing the bruise on
her head, which had risen to a large bump, he was worried that she might have suffered a
concussion. He and O.J. had been friends since childhood, and he had never known O.J. to
do what Nicole said he did. However, the bump on her head, the dirt on her pants, her trip
to the police station, her complaint of a headache and her angry insistence that she was
"going to get O.J. for what he did" to her, convinced him that O.J. must have
hit her.
It angered him, and he advised her "to go all the way." He
did not know that Nicole had gone after Michelle in a jealous rage after confronting O.J.
with what she thought was proof of his infidelity. Therefore, it could not have occurred
to him that "what O.J. did to her," how he had hurt her and what she was so
angry about, was something other than him hitting her. The doctor who examined her,
stitched no cut or torn skin, applied no dressings, prescribed no medication. Nicole was
left with no scars or injuries Cowlings saw no blood, no black eye, no cut lip. He saw no
marks on her body that were inconsistent with O.J.s story of a rough, angry
wrestling match between a strong, determined woman and a bigger, stronger man.
Darden ChristopherDeputy
DA. He was seen by many African-Americans as a token chosen because of his color to
diffuse the issue of racial prejudice in the prosecutions handling of the case.
Darden, whose job it had been for awhile to prosecute bad cops, was extremely reluctant to
accept any evidence that pointed to race as a motive for police misconduct. As a
prosecutor in the case against O.J. Simpson he accepted all of the charges of spouse-abuse
made against him with little or no evidence. He viciously attacked Rosa Lopez and Robert
Heidstra with questions designed only to call attention to their limited education and
lower socio-economic status. For his success in taking advantage of their fear of him and
their poor command of the language, he was rewarded by expert commentator opinion that he
"discredited" Rosa Lopez and got Robert Heidstra to admit he saw "a white
Bronco" driving away from Bundy.
The fact that Ms. Lopez held her own against Darden when she got a
competent interpreter, did not make a big impression with the press. The fact that
Heidstra did not say he saw a white Bronco, and the vehicle he did see was heading away
from O.J.s Rockingham estate, was similarly played down or ignored. What did get
attention was Dardens attempt to get Heidstra to say he heard "a black
man" arguing with a younger man at the crime scene and his plea to keep
Fuhrmans use of the n-word away from the jurors. He is best remembered for his
disastrous glove demonstration, which allowed Johnnie Cochran to argue, "If it
doesnt fit, you must acquit."
Deedrick, DouglasFBI
hair and fiber expert. Testified that hair in the knit cap found at the murder scene
and in both bloody gloves was consistent with O.J. Simpsons. His most damaging
testimony, however, concerned parallel line imprints on the envelope on Bundy that defense
expert Henry Lee identified as being a possible shoeprint. According to Deedrick, the
pattern of lines in question were most likely left by Ron Goldmans trousers. He was
the second FBI agent (see Bodziak, William) to claim that Dr. Lee erred in seeing possible
evidence of two people involved in the killing.
DesdemonaThe wife
falsely accused of infidelity in Shakespeares play, Othello. As part of
the setup to make Othello believe that she was having an affair with Casio, Iago planted
the idea in Othellos mind that he had good reason to be jealous. To convince him, he
planted subtle suggestions that innocent behavior on the part of Casio and Desdemona was
actually guilty behavior. To cap it off, Iago used a duplicate of a distinctive
handkerchief Othello had given to Desdemona and she had lost, to give to Casio. He then
maneuvered Othello into secretly observing Casio with the handkerchief. The sight was so
upsetting to Othello that it triggered an epileptic seizure. But he still wasnt
convinced until Iago persuaded him to ask Desdemona if she still had handkerchief, knowing
that she would lie about it to protect herself from Othellos anger. She did. Her lie
is what sealed her doom, by convincing Othello that she was a liar and Iago must have been
telling the truth.
Dietz, ParkFBI
profiler and forensic psychiatrist. Using only the prosecutions idea of
evidence that O.J. beat Nicole, Dietz lent the credibility of his association with the FBI
as well as Harvard and Johns Hopkins, to characterize Simpson as a spouse-abuser. He said
that O.J. would have continued to abuse Nicole with no reliable data that he ever
did. Even at that, he could not find a pattern of escalation that matched the profile of a
would-be killer. His expert testimony was allowed despite the fact that he never examined
Simpson himself (see Walker, Dr. Lenore).
Douroux, BernieDriver
of the truck that towed O.J.s Bronco to the impound garage (see Viertels).
By the time he hooked up the Bronco, the sun was up and the news was out that the Bronco
might have been involved in a bloody homicide. He had a clear view of the vehicles
interior under the best possible lighting conditions. He testified that he saw now blood
in the Bronco.
Dream Evidence(See Ron
Shipp). In Shakespeares play, Othello, the villain, Iago, tells the tittle
character of his wifes infidelity by way of a dream Casio supposedly divulged to him
while he was asleep.
Dunne, DominickStaff
writer for Vanity Fair magazine. He wrote a best-selling book in the 80s about a
murder in Connecticut, which was tied to the Kennedy family. As an author commissioned to
write a book about the Brentwood murders, he was granted a permanent seat in Judge
Itos courtroom. A frequent talk show guest, his opinions, together with fellow
permanent seat-holder, Jeffrey Toobin, and talk-show host, Geraldo Revera, form a large
body of what most people believe about O.J. Simpson. Dunne sat with the Goldmans
during the criminal trial and became friends with Mark Fuhrman, whose second book is about
the murder in Connecticut that made Dunne a best-selling writer. He called Fuhrmans
first book about the murder that forever linked Fuhrmans name to O.J. Simpsons
downfall, "...wonderful."
EDTAThe chemical used in
purple-top test tubes to keep blood from clotting. When Nurse Thano Peratis drew O.J.
Simpsons blood directly from his body, he put it in a purple-top test tube and shook
it up to allow the EDTA blood preservative coating the sides to mix with the blood.
O.J.s defense team reasoned that a simple, straightforward way of determining
whether or not his blood was planted in incriminating places, was to see if blood
collected in those places on untreated cloth swatches contained EDTA.
The prosecutors leaped to accept the challenge, announcing that they
were confident no EDTA would be found. Deputy DA Rockney Harmon was on loan to the LA
County prosecutors from Alameda for his expertise in DNA. He wrote to Agent Roger Martz of
the FBI crime lab requesting that he test samples of evidence "to refute defense
charges" that blood from Nicoles reference vial as well as O.J.s had been
planted. They refused to send Martz samples of the Bundy blood drops identified as
O.J.s because they said they didnt have enough to go around. When the results
came back positive from the samples they did send, they refused to accept them or call
experts to support their reasons for not accepting them. They argued, instead, that it
would take too much time and prove nothing.
The defense then called Martz as well as its own expert witness, Dr.
Fredric Reiders, the worlds leading expert on EDTA. Martz confirmed the presence of
EDTA but said that the amount could have occurred naturally in O.J.s blood. Reiders
said that anyone with that amount of EDTA in his blood would bleed to death from a minor
cut because the blood would not clog. Since O.J. had flown all the way to Chicago with a
minor cut, and all the way back to LA with a major one, the blood in question could not
have come directly from his body if Reiders was correct.
Edwards, JohnOne of
two LAPD officers who responded to the infamous 911 call at Rockingham in 1989 (see
Abudrahn, Michelle and Gilbert, Sharyn). Edwards and his partner, rookie trainee Patricia
Milewski, were patrolling near the Simpson estate when they got a call from emergency
operator Sharyn Gilbert. Gilbert told the officers that she had heard screams on an open
line and that a woman was being beaten. She did not tell them that the woman being beaten
had made the call or that only one woman was involved. Gilbert and Edwards assumed these
things, which seemed apparent from the information they had to work with. Edwards and
Milewski then heard something over their radio about "...a black male," not
knowing that an operator next to Gilbert was describing another emergency.
The officers hurried to 360 N. Rockingham under the assumption that a
woman being physically assaulted by a black man had somehow managed to call 911, and they
were going to her rescue.
The patrol car went past the Rockingham gate and pulled into the drive
on Ashford. Only after Edwards told the maid on the intercom what he thought was going on,
did Nicole emerge from the bushes and fall into his arms with a story to tell that matched
his impression. He then saw O.J. Simpson, a black male, enraged and outraged that the
police would want to treat his idea of a minor incident like a criminal act. Edwards saw a
man who couldnt see anything wrong with beating his wife. He saw all the evidence of
a battered wifeincluding a black eye that didnt show up on any of the photos
he took of her face, and a one inch cut on her lip that didnt show up on the photos,
didnt bleed, and left no scar.
Nicole had a bruise on the underside of her right arm. Though O.J.
couldnt explain it, he took responsibility for it, assuming that it must have
happened during their tussle. He was not present when Michelle went to the right, rear
door of the police car and tried to pull Nicole out by her right arm. More than likely,
that bruise, which Edwards did not report, happened then, in the excitement of the moment
when Michelle applied more pressure to the arm than anyone realized.
A bruise on Nicoles collar was consistent with O.J.s story
of grabbing her in a headlock and shoving her out of their bedroom. The imprint of
someones fingers that Edwards said he saw on the side of Nicoles neck, was
consistent with the slapping sound recorded off of Gilberts emergency line. The fact
that it didnt show up in any photos or require any treatment was consistent with a
blow that didnt have much power behind itlike the slap of a small woman. The
story Nicole told of O.J. pulling her hair is more consistent with what a woman would do
to another woman in a fightexcept for the story that Mark Fuhrman told in the
McKinny tapes. In that incident, which supposedly happened in 1978, he boasted of grabbing
a criminal suspects girlfriend by her hair and flinging her down a flight of stairs.
Entrenching ToolA spade-like tool with a short
handle and sharp, folding blade used by soldiers as a spade or a pick to dig holes in the
ground. It can also be used as a weapon in hand-to-hand combat. It was one of the many
weapons falsely reported to have been found, with blood on it, around O.J. Simpsons
home or his hotel in Chicago. The cumulative affect of such reports was to reinforce the
idea that O.J. Simpson was a murderer, notwithstanding later demonstrations that the
reports had no basis in fact. Reports not given the attention of the entrenching tool as a
demonstrable error, have been repeated so often as true that few people have bothered to
track down their source (see Blood Trail, Blue/Black Fibers).
EnvelopeThe envelope containing Juditha
Browns prescription glasses. The known size of the envelope and its position
next to Mark Fuhrmans shoe in the full-size photograph of him pointing to the bloody
glove at Bundy makes it possible to calculate his shoe size precisely. Juditha Brown
thought that she had left her glasses behind at Mezzalunas. They could just as
easily have been stolen by someone at the table and put next to the curb outside where
they could be found later as an excuse for Ron to show up "unexpectedly" at
Bundy (see Brown, Denise).
FBIFederal Bureau of Investigation. Before
the O.J. Simpson trial, almost everyone in the country saw the FBIs lab facilities
and experts in charge as the worlds best at finding and analyzing the relevant
facts. The mere invocation of FBI credentials was enough to create the universal
expectation that the truth would be sought with the most sophisticated equipment and the
highest standards of professional conduct anywhere in the world. The man most responsible
for that reputation in the FBI lab was Dr. Henry Lee, who established and oversaw the
polices and practices which made that universal perception a reality for many years.
During the O.J. Simpson criminal trial, the prosecution, in an official
letter, called upon the FBI to prove that their evidence against the accused was precisely
what it appeared to be. Despite all reason and all evidence to the contrary, that is what
every expert representative of the FBI did in both trials and in a polygraph test taken by
Mark Fuhrman at the behest of his publishers. In all, six FBI agents or former agents
offered testimony against Simpson. A former polygraph expert for the FBI (see Minor, Paul)
lent his credentials to the publishers of Mark Fuhrmans first book by testing
Fuhrman without independent witnesses and declaring that he told the truth. Henry Lee and
Fredric Whitehurst, the only experts associated with the FBI to offer testimony for the
defense, were either restricted in their ability to examine evidence or prohibited from
testifying.
Ferrell, MikeThe
detective assigned to investigate Nicoles 89 battering complaint against O.J. Though
Nicole declined to press charges against O.J., California law required the police to
arrest the accused if the alleged victim appeared to be injured. If they had independent
verification of the charge, they were required by law to bring charges of their own.
Ferrell had three witnesses, two who said that there was no battery on the day of the
incident, and all three who agreed the next day that it wasnt as bad as it had
appeared. He had physical evidence that could have been read either way until you took a
cold, hard looked at it both ways.
To show the city attorney that this was truly a case of a
spouse-abusers latest assault, as opposed to one drunken fight that got out of hand,
he asked other officers who had responded to previous 911 calls at Rockingham if they had
seen anything like it. His only response came in Mark Fuhrmans letter describing his
version of the 85 incident with O.J., Nicole, and the baseball bat. That was the
basis upon which O.J. pled "No contest" to the complaint Nicole made against him
on New Years Day 1989 but refused to bring charges the next day . There was no record of a
911 call made from Rockingham in 85, no statement by Nicole that she made one (she
called Westec), and no other police officer, including Fuhrmans partner, told
Ferrall a similar story.
Fenjves, PabloNeighbor
of Nicole Brown Simpson. He heard a dogs "plaintive wail" at 10:15 or
10:20 on the night of the murders. Ignoring all evidence that the dog was silent until
15-20 minutes later, Marcia Clark used Fenjves estimate of the time he heard the
dog, based on his impression of when a news program began and ended, to mark when the
killings at Bundy began. Without that extra time, O.J. could not have committed the crime.
He could not have left all of the evidence that was left at Rockingham, cleaned up or
disposed of all the evidence that wasnt found anywhere, and been clean, dressed and
ready to go to the airport when he was seen by the limo driver at 10:54. The plaintiffs in
the civil trial made up for the time problem by assuming the killing was over in seconds,
that Kato Kaelins estimate of when he heard the thumps were off by five or ten
minutes, and "someone" cleaned up after O.J. It worked. O.J. lost.
Ferrara, RachelFriend
of Kato Kaelin. Kaelin was talking to her on the telephone when he heard and felt
three hard thumps no later than 10:45. Both Kaelin and Ferrara estimated that the thumps
occurred ten or fifteen minutes after they checked the time at 10:30. Ferrara estimated
that the call ended at 10:50. If she was correct, it would have been impossible for O.J.
to have committed the crime.
Fischman, Cora and RonClose
friends of O.J. and Nicole. Cora was Nicoles jogging partner and confidante.
She attended the childrens dance recital with Nicole, Denise, Dominique, O.J. and
her husband Ron. She reported nothing strange in O.J.s behavior at the recital. She
recalled (incorrectly) that he was wearing loafers without socks. She talked her husband
into taking a picture of O.J. with Sydney. That picture, which Denise did not learn about
until the trial, is the only thing that stands in the way of the shoes he wore to the
recital being falsely, but convincingly identified as Bruno Magli Lorenzos. They fit the
general description of the killers Lorenzos, but Ron Fischmans picture proved
that they were a different brand.
The police, the FBI and the prosecutors assumed that O.J. left the
clear imprints of "his" Bruno Maglis in blood because he wasnt thinking
about them. Nevertheless, the killer had to be thinking about the shoes he wore to the
recital to come so close to what they looked like. O.J. had no way of knowing whether the
photo Ron Fischman took of him three hours before the killing would include the shoes. In
any case, he had no reason to take them off and put on a pair that might look the same to
eyewitnesses like Cora and Denise.
On the weekend before Nicole was murdered, Cora was with her when
Nicole discovered that two identical keys to her house and gate were missing. Cora could
not remember whether Nicole kept one key or two on a ring attached to a chain on her gate
when they went running. But she did recall Nicole saying that she thought O.J. had them,
then changing her mind and deciding that Faye had them. The keys the maid said were
missing around that time were on a ring with many keys (see Keys).
Flammer, E. J.Freelance
photographer. He was one of two 20-year-old photographers (see Scull, Harry) who
claimed to have taken photos of O.J. Simpson wearing Bruno Magli Lorenzos at a
Bills/Dolphins game on September 26, 1993. Both men hired the same agent to sell their
photos to the media (see McCelroy, Rob). E.J. Flammer came forward with his photos in the
last week of December 1996, after the defenses only photo expert made errors that
proved he didnt know how the photos were faked.
Flammer, EdThe Father
of E. J. He arranged for his son to take the 93 photos as part of a special
celebration he organized for O.J. He was one of the five men in the group photo, which
showed O.J. wearing the Bruno Maglis. Two of the remaining four were close friends of his.
The other two were the public relations director and assistant director for the Buffalo
Bills (see Lynch, Denny and Munson, Bill), the only people with the resources to insure
that no other photos where taken that day of O.J.s shoes.
Fuhrman, MarkFirst
detective on the Bundy murder scene, responsible for making Rockingham a murder scene as
well. His negative influence on O.J. Simpsons life went back to a minor
intrusion in the last quarter of 1985, that he turned into a "pattern of abuse"
in the first month of 1989. With only three years of experience as a homicide detective
and being off call for that night, he was, nevertheless, the first one called by his boss
Ron Phillips who misrepresented himself in the criminal trial as being Fuhrmans
partner. Fuhrmans real partner was Brad Roberts, who had less experience as a
homicide detective than Fuhrman did. Between them, they found, highlighted, or interpreted
every scrap of evidence linking Simpson to the Bundy crime scene (note: the blue/black
fibers said by Marcia Clark to have come from a blue/black sweatsuit, do not link O.J. to
the murder scene). If O.J. didnt murder the people he was accused of murdering,
Fuhrman and Roberts, with only two or three other active plotters, were the only ones who
could have.
Fujisaki, HiroshiThe judge in the civil case.
He ruled consistently in favor of the plaintiffs. He allowed hearsay evidence attributed
to Nicole by way of a phone call and written documents to be presented against O.J.
without authentication that they were what they were reported to be. He allowed the
Flammer photographs to be presented late in the case as evidence that O.J. wore the Bruno
Magli Lorenzos during a football game on October 26, 1993 without giving the defense
adequate time to prepare an aggressive defense. He denied the defense the opportunity to
question Mark Fuhrman or to argue that he had anything to do with the evidence against
Simpson. He denied the defense the opportunity to challenge Faye Resnicks drug
habit, and therefore her credibility. He denied them the opportunity to argue that O.J.
was framed.
Fung, DennisLAPD criminalist. He supervised
the collection of evidence at Bundy and Rockingham beginning with Rockingham. He got there
at 7:00 a.m. when it was light enough to see the blood drops on the driveway but not light
enough to see their direction. That question was answered for him immediately by Mark
Fuhrman and his partner Brad Roberts who told the cop by the gate and everyone entering
the property to watch out for the blood drops going up the driveway.
When Roberts, began to lay down markers for the location of O.J.s
blood drops, Fung stopped him. His poor record keeping made him vulnerable to attack on
several fronts by defense attorney Barry Scheck in the vital areas of chain of custody,
compromise and contamination of evidence. By not counting and recording the number of
swatches used to collect blood samples, for instance, he made it possible for blood
samples to be switched before testing. Samples collected by his subordinate, Andrea
Mazzola, showed clear signs of being switched.